Product Filter

Best Selling Candy

  1. Home
  2. Best Selling Candy
  3. Old Fashioned
Filter by
Filter by

280 products found in Best Selling Candy

Sold out

Quick View Cella's Dark Chocolate Covered Cherries 5oz W/ Liquid Filling - Sweets and Geeks
Cella's Dark Chocolate Covered Cherries - 5oz Box
  • $4.99
Quick View
Zotz Cherry 8oz Peg Bag
  • $3.49

Sold out

Quick View
Skippy Chocolate Peanut Butter 1.5oz Bar
  • From $1.99
Quick View Claey's Natural Old Fashion Hard Candies 6oz Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Claey's Licorice Hard Candies 6oz Peg Bag
  • $1.99
Quick View Zachary Old Fashion Cherry Creme Drops 6.5oz - Sweets and Geeks
Zachary Cherry Creme Drops 6.5oz Peg Bag
  • $2.99
Quick View SUNKIST SOURS TIN - Sweets and Geeks
Sunkist Sours Tangerine Orange 1.7oz Tin
  • From $2.99

Sold out

Quick View
Boone Village Rock Crystal Candy Cherry
  • From $1.25
Quick View Zachary Old Fashion Vanilla Creme Drops 6.5oz - Sweets and Geeks
Zachary Vanilla Creme Drops 6.5oz Peg Bag
  • $2.99
Quick View
Skippy Wafer Peanut Butter & Chocolate 1.3oz Bar
  • From $1.99
Quick View
David's Sunflower Seeds Original 5.25oz Peg Bag
  • $2.49

Sold out

Quick View Easies S'more Flavored Coated Marshmallows 1.9oz - Sweets and Geeks
Easies S'more Flavored Coated Marshmallows 1.9oz
  • From $1.49
Quick View
Tiny N Tart Candy 1.5oz Pack
  • From $1.99
Quick View
Espeez Cinna-Pix cinnamon Toothpicks
  • From $1.49

Sold out

Quick View Reggie Chocolate Covered Caramel and Peanut Baseball Bar 1.8oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reggie! 1.8oz Bar
  • From $2.49
Quick View
Claey's Anise Hard Candies 6oz Peg Bag
  • $2.49
Quick View
Country Time Licorice Ropes 3oz Peg Bags (SNG 12)
  • $2.49
Quick View Reed's Peppermint Candy Roll - Sweets and Geeks
Reed's Peppermint 1oz Roll
  • From $1.49
Quick View
Lucky Charms Marshmallows 7oz Laydown Bag (SNG16-8)
  • $3.49
Quick View
Boone Village Rock Crystal Candy Maple Syrup
  • From $1.25

Sold out

Quick View OSU Buckeyes 14.5 oz Box - Sweets and Geeks
OSU Buckeyes 14.5oz Tray
  • $19.99

Sold out

Quick View
Boone Village Rock Crystal Candy Watermelon
  • From $1.25
Quick View Goetz Caramel Creams 100 Count - Sweets and Geeks
Caramel Creams 100 Count 2.5lb Tub
  • $15.99

Sold out

Quick View
Boone Village Rock Crystal Candy Grape
  • From $1.25

Sold out

Quick View
DeMet's Turtles Dark Chocolate Pecan 3pc 1.76oz Pouch
  • From $1.99
Quick View
Espeez Cinn-A-Rock 0.8oz Rock Candy
  • From $1.49
Quick View
Boone Village Rock Crystal Candy Pineapple
  • From $1.25
Quick View
Creme Savers Peg Bags Choc & Caramel Creme 3oz
  • $1.99
Quick View
Chick-O-Stick Extra Small Changemaker 0.35oz Stick
  • From $0.33